How to Stop Getting Defensive in the Heat of the Moment (4 Steps That Actually Work)
Let’s be real, most of us don’t plan on getting defensive. It’s not like we wake up and say, “Today’s the day I ruin a conversation with a friend by going full courtroom cross-examiner.”
But then bam - someone says something, your chest tightens, your ears get hot, and suddenly you’re defending yourself like you’re on trial for a crime you didn’t commit.
I know that pattern too well because this is my biggest struggle in relationships. And it wasn’t until I started working through it (therapy, books, breathing exercises, you name it) that I found an actual framework that helps. These four steps? They’re my go-to now. Let’s walk through them together.
Step 1: Pause—Literally Freeze Time
You know that moment when your heart starts racing, your voice gets loud, and your body goes into fight mode?
Yeah, that’s your cue to hit pause.
Even a tiny pause (just a breath or two) can interrupt the cycle. Why? Because your brain needs about 400 milliseconds to form a conscious thought. That momentary slowdown gives your rational brain time to catch up and say, “Hey, we don’t need to go full Mortal Kombat right now.”
Try saying something to yourself like, “Pause. We’re safe. Let’s respond, not react.”
Step 2: Ask Yourself—Why Am I Getting Defensive Right Now?
This one’s harder. But it’s also where everything starts to shift.
For me, I realized that 90% of my defensiveness traces back to two things: being misunderstood or being mischaracterized. And the kicker? I can’t control how other people perceive me. That realization alone changed how I show up in tough moments.
Sometimes it’s helpful to trace the origin of your defensiveness. For me, it was being bullied in high school for 18 months straight. My body learned to stay in fight mode. But once I understood that, I could stop blaming people in the present for a wound from the past.
Step 3: Name What You’re Feeling (Not What They Did)
I used to think “I feel like you’re being rude” was a proper feeling statement. Spoiler alert: it’s not. That’s just a sneaky accusation wearing a fake mustache.
Instead, I had to learn to identify actual emotions: “I feel hurt,” “I feel dismissed,” “I feel confused.” The tool that helped me? The emotions wheel. (Seriously—Google it. Life-changing.)
When you identify what’s going on inside you, it keeps the focus where it belongs. On what you’re feeling—not what you assume they intended.
Step 4: Test the Assumption—Out Loud
This is the one that takes guts.
When I’m feeling defensive, it’s usually because my brain decided someone’s out to get me. But most of the time? They’re not. I just assumed their tone or comment meant something it didn’t.
So I’ve started asking things like:
“Hey, that comment felt a little sharp—was that your intention?”
“I might be reading into this, but are you upset with me?”
It feels awkward at first. Vulnerable. Exposed. But it also gives the other person a chance to clarify—and gives me a chance to breathe again.
Let’s Recap
The next time someone says something that triggers you, try walking through these four steps:
Pause
Ask why you’re defensive
Name the emotion you’re feeling
Test the assumption instead of assuming the worst
This simple framework has helped me de-escalate countless moments that could’ve turned into blowups. It's not about being perfect—it's about choosing peace over pride, and connection over control.
If this blog resonated, you'll love the full video I recorded on this topic.
Zoe Asher is a friendship and connection coach, corporate speaker, and host of the Accidentally Intentional podcast. Through practical tools and real talk, she helps people go from feeling disconnected to building friendships that actually last. Her mission is simple: destroy loneliness and teach the skill of meaningful connection — whether that’s in everyday life or in the workplace.
🗣 Want Zoe to speak at your event or work with your team? Click here to learn more.
🎙 Or keep hanging out with her on the Accidentally Intentional podcast.